Best Faith-Based Credit Unions in Buffalo, New York
59 credit unions have a branch within 25 miles of downtown Buffalo. We rank them by the everyday perks they report, like joining online and mobile deposit, plus how many branches they have in the area.
Data from the NCUA · as of Mar 31, 2026
The NCUA is the U.S. government agency that regulates credit unions and insures deposits at most of them (like the FDIC for banks). Credit unions report these facts to it every three months. The NCUA doesn’t rank or endorse anyone: the ranking is ours, built from its public data as of Mar 31, 2026.
- Ranked by perks and branches
Rankings can’t be bought
Credit unions can’t pay to change their rank or to win an award. Sponsored listings are paid for and always labelled Sponsored. They can appear above or within a list, but they never get a rank number or an award.
- How we rank
5 credit unions match your filters in the Buffalo area
Most useful perks first, then branches in the area
- Rank 9

Ukrainian Credit Union
Why #913 of 18 points: all 5 everyday perks, 2 more and 2 branches in the Buffalo area
Everyday perks 2 points each10 of 10
- Has it: Join online
- Has it: $0/mo checking
- Has it: Mobile deposit
- Has it: Mobile payments
- Has it: Transfers to banks
More perks 1 point each2 of 5
- Not reported: Shared branches
- Not reported: Credit builder
- Has it: First-home help
- Not reported: Money coaching
- Has it: Apply for loans
Branches in the Buffalo area1 of 3
2 branches. 2 to 4 branches: 1 point.
13 of 18 points. Ties go to more branches in the Buffalo area, then more members. How we rank
- Join online
- $0/mo checking
- Mobile deposit
- Mobile payments
2 branches in the Buffalo area
Mid-size · 28K members · $422.8M in assets
- Rank 36C
Cadets Credit Union
Why #366 of 18 points: 2 of 5 everyday perks, 1 more and 2 branches in the Buffalo area
Everyday perks 2 points each4 of 10
- Has it: Join online
- Has it: $0/mo checking
- Not reported: Mobile deposit
- Not reported: Mobile payments
- Not reported: Transfers to banks
More perks 1 point each1 of 5
- Not reported: Shared branches
- Not reported: Credit builder
- Not reported: First-home help
- Not reported: Money coaching
- Has it: Apply for loans
Branches in the Buffalo area1 of 3
2 branches. 2 to 4 branches: 1 point.
6 of 18 points. Ties go to more branches in the Buffalo area, then more members. How we rank
- Join online
- $0/mo checking
- Apply for loans
2 branches in the Buffalo area
Small · 1K members · $17.8M in assets
- Rank 37

Sjp Credit Union
Why #376 of 18 points: 2 of 5 everyday perks, 2 more and 1 branch in the Buffalo area
Everyday perks 2 points each4 of 10
- Has it: Join online
- Has it: $0/mo checking
- Not reported: Mobile deposit
- Not reported: Mobile payments
- Not reported: Transfers to banks
More perks 1 point each2 of 5
- Not reported: Shared branches
- Not reported: Credit builder
- Not reported: First-home help
- Has it: Money coaching
- Has it: Apply for loans
Branches in the Buffalo area0 of 3
1 branch. Fewer than 2 branches: no points.
6 of 18 points. Ties go to more branches in the Buffalo area, then more members. How we rank
- Join online
- $0/mo checking
- Money coaching
- Apply for loans
1 branch in the Buffalo area
Small · 7K members · $186M in assets
- Rank 53SJ
Saint John A M E Credit Union
Why #531 of 18 points: 0 of 5 everyday perks, 1 more and 1 branch in the Buffalo area
Everyday perks 2 points each0 of 10
- Not reported: Join online
- Not reported: $0/mo checking
- Not reported: Mobile deposit
- Not reported: Mobile payments
- Not reported: Transfers to banks
More perks 1 point each1 of 5
- Not reported: Shared branches
- Has it: Credit builder
- Not reported: First-home help
- Not reported: Money coaching
- Not reported: Apply for loans
Branches in the Buffalo area0 of 3
1 branch. Fewer than 2 branches: no points.
1 of 18 points. Ties go to more branches in the Buffalo area, then more members. How we rank
- Credit builder
1 branch in the Buffalo area
Small · 170 members · $200,727 in assets
- Rank 57SJ
St. John United Credit Union
Why #570 of 18 points: 0 of 5 everyday perks and 1 branch in the Buffalo area
Everyday perks 2 points each0 of 10
- Not reported: Join online
- Not reported: $0/mo checking
- Not reported: Mobile deposit
- Not reported: Mobile payments
- Not reported: Transfers to banks
More perks 1 point each0 of 5
- Not reported: Shared branches
- Not reported: Credit builder
- Not reported: First-home help
- Not reported: Money coaching
- Not reported: Apply for loans
Branches in the Buffalo area0 of 3
1 branch. Fewer than 2 branches: no points.
0 of 18 points. Ties go to more branches in the Buffalo area, then more members. How we rank
0 of 10 perks1 branch in the Buffalo area
Small · 411 members · $1.1M in assets
How we rank
Who’s on this list. Federally insured credit unions with at least one branch within 25 miles of downtown Buffalo, including suburbs and branches across a state line.
What we count. Ten perks each credit union reports. Five everyday ones count double: joining online, checking with no monthly fee, mobile deposit, mobile payments and transfers to other banks. Five count once: shared branches, credit-builder loans, first-time homebuyer help, money coaching and applying for loans online. Then up to 3 points for branches in the area.
Ties. The one with more branches in the area goes first, then the one with more members. Size and assets are shown so you can compare, but they only break ties.
Best here means the most useful everyday perks, plus branches in the Buffalo area. Rates, fees and whether you can join aren’t part of the score, so check those too.
Credit unions report these perks themselves. We don’t test them, and a missing perk may just be unreported, so ask the credit union.
Common questions
What’s the best credit union in Buffalo?
Cornerstone Community Credit Union ranks #1 of 59 credit unions with a branch in the Buffalo area. It reports 10 of 10 perks, including join online, $0/mo checking, mobile deposit, and has 6 branches here. Whether it’s best for you depends on whether you can join and on its rates and fees, which we don’t score.
Which credit unions in Buffalo can I join?
Each credit union sets its own rules. 23 of the 59 here are open to people who live, work or go to school in their area. Others mainly serve certain employers, schools, the military or faith groups, and family members often qualify too. Check each one’s site before you apply.
How is this list ranked?
By the perks each credit union reports to the NCUA, plus how many branches it has within 25 miles of downtown Buffalo. Five everyday perks count double: joining online, checking with no monthly fee, mobile deposit, mobile payments and transfers to other banks. Credit unions can’t pay to rank higher or to win an award.
More in New York
- All credit unions in New York
- Credit unions in New York
- Credit unions in Rochester
- Credit unions in Albany
- Credit unions in Syracuse
- Best Military Credit Unions in New York
- Best Credit Unions for Teachers in New York
- Best Credit Unions for Government Employees in New York
- Best Credit Unions for Healthcare Workers in New York






